Superman and me at Scarborough Beach

As published in the Providence Sunday Journal, June 19, 2022. Above, my dad with my older brother Rob, left, and me at Scarborough Beach in 1961.

I envy them as they pass my house pulling red wagons with toddlers in tow: the new dads.

That was me 27 years ago when we moved to the neighborhood. Back when we had three children under age 5. Back when I was Superman.

My kids were all giggles and wide eyes when I spun a basketball on my index finger. They clapped when I made a kite soar against the cloudless sky at our Block Island rental. And if thunder cracked like gunshots during a summer storm, they climbed into my arms. I assured them the heavens would calm.

But when a fall gashed my younger son Evan’s hand in our backyard, his blood was my Kryptonite. I was Everyman, not Superman, face ashen and skin coated in sweat. 

My kids saw me as Everyman on other occasions, too, like when I cursed the drivers who cut me off on Route 95 and sometimes snapped at our dog and, achingly, when I was putting Evan to bed one night.

I don’t recall what prompted his question, but it startled me.

“Do you miss your dad?” he asked with an innocence that belongs only to children. My father died three months after Evan was born. The last time I had seen him, Dad had handed me the bill for his recent, long-overdue doctor’s visit.

“Yes, I do,” I said. Evan’s eyes asked me for more.

“You know what I think?” I said, my Everyman voice quavering. “My father’s alive every time we talk about him. Maybe that’s what heaven is.”

My 5-year-old set me straight. “You don’t really go to heaven,” he said matter-of-factly. “You’re buried. Heaven’s where you go in your head.”

I have often considered the shocking wisdom of my son’s words that night, and I’m thinking of them now.

In my head, I see my dad in black-and-white glossies from family photo albums: as a Marine Corps officer getting his commission, as a dean of students at Brown, smoking a cigarette and looking like George Peppard. 

I see him calmly whisking fourth-grade me to the emergency room at Roger Williams Hospital after I gashed my head on the corner of a coffee table while horsing around with my older brother.

And in a less-than-heavenly reverie, I see him 20 years later in his two-room apartment on Waterman Avenue in North Providence, writing a letter that recently came into my possession. It’s to his brother in New Hampshire. 

In his elegant hand, my dad notes that he “finally got an underpaying, paralyzingly dull job, low wages, no benefits, but thank God a check every week.” He reports he has emphysema and flashes his sharp wit: “The diagnostician wants to run a series of tests. I asked if he were paying.” He closes with reassurances: “I write only to inform not alarm you. You see, with you out there and the boys back here, I have a lot going for me.”

Now in my head, I go to another heaven – to Dad and me in the water at Scarborough Beach on a bright October day. I am 7 years old and feel the strong tug of the undertow as a rising wave approaches. My father is beside me, lean and athletic.

As the wave curls and begins to break, I dive to ride it, arms reaching for the shore. But the water pounds me and I am upended in the churning tumult until, yanking me upward by my wrists, Dad plucks me from the ocean chaos.

We stand in the white sea foam laughing, Superman and me.


No watercolors or impressionism here, this is fine art photography at its best.
Thanks John!

Wow John… heartfelt, loving, and spanning the generations…absolutely fantastic writing!

Ernie Santoro

Wow so very powerful John, thanks for the wonderful feeling/memories this writing evoked.
Best, Bridget

Wow! Beautiful writing. May we always cherish the Superman memories of our Dads.

vincegebhart1gmailcom June 23, 2022 at 1:20 pm

Dear John,

Just thought I would drop you a little note in response to your latest contribution to Projo. First, thanks for remembering your dad which reminds us all of our obligation to remember and honor our fathers. After all, doing so is the fifth of the ten commandments: “Honor thy father and thy mother…”. We really have no choice if we expect to obey God in this connection.

But I would add a couple of thoughts for your consideration. God represents himself often in the Bible as a “Father” both in the New and Old Testaments. I was struck in your piece by the final scene in which your dad, your Superman, plucked you from the rough surf at Scarborough. Can’t life itself be pictured by that rough surf? We often need someone beyond a mere Everyman or our imagined Superman to save us from life’s tumultuous twists and turns, troubles and sorrows, sicknesses and death. The God of the Bible is just such a Father. Jesus, the God-Man directs us this way, does he not, in the Lord’s Prayer in the opening line, “Our Father who art in heaven”. So, we all have human fathers who like us are often flawed and manifestly limited, but for the Christian we truly have a divine being as our Father who knows us and looks out for us beyond what any Superman can accomplish.

I might add something a bit more difficult, perhaps. The notion that “heaven” is a state of mind or is only found in one’s memory is certainly at minimum, unbiblical. The Christian doctrine of salvation has as its end an eternal life, body and soul, in a place called heaven. I know you are aware of this, but might have difficulty with the supernatural character of this teaching. Our Lord did not come to the earth to provide good memories only to have them eventually and permanently forgotten. He came, died and rose again in order to procure for his people eternal life, body and soul in a place which the Bible calls in the Book of Revelation the new heavens and the new earth. The early martyrs of the church endured unimaginable suffering to gain this life as have countless protestants since the Reformation. It is a powerful doctrine which remains relevant in our day.

Sorry I got a little preachy on you…

Warmest regards, CV


Thanks, Vin. Your words are thoughtful, as always, and not “preachy,” at least not to my ears. The strength of your faith is reflected in the power of your prose, and I admire both. Love our ongoing correspondence over the last few years, often around matters like these. To be continued!

Leave a Reply

Name and email address are required. Your email address will not be published.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <pre> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong> 

%d bloggers like this: